
As much as I loved
Donnie Darko, I came into
Southland Tales with great caution. For one thing, I don't like the titles font.

In fact, I despise it with the power of a thousand suns. Also, the film has taken
quite a beating from the critics. I don't mind disagreeing with a few critics, but when every review you read says that a movie is a trainwreck, there must be
something to it.
In point of fact,
Southland Tales does have some problems. It runs a bit long, is packed with exposition, and it makes the mistake of having entirely too much to say. But is it the absolute disaster that it's been made out to be? Personally, I didn't think it was all that bad, to be honest.
In a a prologue that attempts to cram three comic books' worth of exposition into a few minutes, we learn that in 2005 a pair of nuclear attacks on Texas have incited World War 3, a four-fronted war against the predictable axis of evil nations. With the Middle Eastern oil resources rendered unavailable, an alternative energy source called "Liquid Karma" is developed, which may or may not be tearing a hole in the universe. Et cetera. The actual plot is (predictably, after all that prologue) labyrinthine in nature, contains about twenty characters, and mainly deals with three major characters: action film star Boxer Santaros (
Dwayne Johnson), who also happens to be the son-in-law of a Republican vice-presidential candidate and a recent amnesiac; Krysta Now (
Sarah Michelle Gellar), a pornstar with a reality/chat show, hit single, and energy drink who assists a group of neo-Marxists in furthering their plot of foiling the '08 presidential election; and Roland Taverner (
Seann William Scott), a neo-Marxist posing as his police officer twin brother Ronald. It all comes together by the end, more or less.
The leads, especially Johnson (aka "The Rock"), all do a pretty good job. Much of the rest of the cast, though, are veterans of television comedy, and this is weird to me. They all bring their respective baggage with them, though
Nora Dunn has less baggage than most and
Jon Lovitz gets about as far away from his staple persona as he can. Then there's
Christopher Lambert in an ice cream truck. Granted, the ice cream truck is full of weapons, but it's Christopher Lambert in an ice cream truck. It's that kind of movie.
Director
Richard Kelly has cited
Kubrick (specifically
Dr. Strangelove) and
Philip K. Dick as major reference points for
Southland Tales, and these are evident, if not overt. (At one point, Lovitz's character, a cop, says "Flow my tears," for no apparent reason other than to reference the title of Dick's book
Flow My Tears The Policeman Said. What's that about? Okay, Kelly, you read a book.) The production design is a little bit weird as well. At one point, Krysta Now talks about the future being "more futuristic than scientists had predicted". Based on some of the technology on display in the film, I'd say that's probably true in this alternate universe the film lives in. They've made some serious leaps to get to where they are in 2008. Also, I'm not sure what the set dressers were thinking, but a lot of the posters and whatnot seemed far too self-referential, and it's a bit difficult to take Boxer Santaros seriously when someone has defaced a wall behind him by stenciling his name and face on it and it shows up in the shot, and this stencil is repeated elsewhere on walls throughout the film. There were a few of these "what-the-heck?" moments, but most of the time things remain on the level, such as that level is. The film is still fairly willfully weird, though. I think that oddness in combination with the intricate plot and unorthodox casting is what ultimately makes the average viewer's head explode. Also, some of the political statements are a bit heavy-handed, in this day and age when we hear just as much squalking about losing our civil liberties as we do squalking about why we need to lose them. If I want to be lectured on politics, I'll go see
Lions For Lambs, thanks. We get it, you don't have to bash us over the head with a clip of elephants having sexual intercourse, amusing as it may be.
(Speaking of which, I never in my life dreamed that I would see a film where I would see two Hummer-style sport utility vehicles having sexual intercourse in basically the same manner as the elephants. I can't say I'm better for it, but I'm pretty sure that that's not how new cars are made. Reasonably sure, at least.)
Somewhere in between
Justin Timberlake pouring a can of Budweiser over his head during a rousing lip-sync production number of the Killers' "All These Things I've Done" and Nora Dunn tasering
John Larroquette in the crotch, I realized what this film was. More than
Dr. Strangelove or
Pulp Fiction or whatever, tonally
Southland Tales is most related to (in my opinion)
Repo Man. Looking at it in that frame of reference, it becomes much less random. Imagine my surprise when
Repo Man was overtly referenced at the end. If nothing else, in
Southland Tales Kelly wears his influences on his sleeve. Put this on the DVD cover: "
Repo Man for the 21st century." You can quote me, guys, I give you permission.
The music for the film is pretty amazing. While Moby, Pixies and Jane's Addiction feature on the soundtrack album, key tracks used in the film are missing from Muse, the aforementioned Killers song, and a (live?) version of Radiohead's "Planet Telex", which is one of their best songs, in my opinion. Kelly continues his tradition of inserting awesome music into his films. Good stuff.
I'm not sure
Southland Tales should have been released as a film. Seeing as the complete material is a sprawling six parts, maybe it would have been better to make it as a TV miniseries or a DVD. The story, especially with its detailed plot and backstory, would be well served by the new menu capabilities that high definition DVD formats have now. I'm sure it will have a long life in the high-def format, whichever format that may be.
I can't say I agree with it, but I'm really not surprised at all of the negative press the film has gotten. At worst, I'd say it was a bit of a misfire, but everyone really seemed to pigpile on this one for not being, well, I don't know what they wanted it to be. It was never meant to be a popcorn film; but were people really expecting that? People complain about films being too homogenized and safe, and Richard Kelly comes rolling in with something completely different and he gets crucified for it. Oh, well. Apparently it's not for everyone. I guess what I'm saying is if you think
Richard Roeper is a bit of a toolshed and think Christopher Lambert in an ice cream truck sounds like good times, you will probably like this movie.
Actually, that's a much better quote for the DVD cover.